Amazon has the Wellness Soft Puppy Bites Natural Grain-Free Treats (3 oz) for $1.99 - $0.40 off coupon (check "Apply $0.40 coupon") - 5% off with Subscribe & Save (can cancel anytime) = $1.49 with free shipping on $35+ or with Prime (extra 15% off for 5+ subscribe and save orders). Petsmart has it for $1.59 w/ coupon SAVE20.