YMMV Double Coupon Method. Amazon has the 12-Pack 16oz Jif Peanut Butter Spread (4 options: Extra Crunchy / Reduced Fat Creamy / Natural Crunchy / Natural Creamy) for $37 - $7.44 off (click coupon under one-time purchase option) - 20% off (check “Save an extra” box, eligible on first S&S order for this product) - 5% off with Subscribe & Save (can cancel at any time) = $21 with free shpping. $1.72 per 16oz jar.